On the plane yesterday, I was forced to listen to a painful dialogue between a young boy and his hip young dad, who was bordering a little too much on the friend side and not enough on the dad side. The dialogue sounded a lot like bickering, where the dad was trying to prove the kid wrong and everything was negotiated. All the while, the dad tried to insert valuable life lessons into the exchange.
When I first started listening in (for the record, I wasn't intentionally trying to eavesdrop- I was trying to read my book, but they were being so loud, as if the dad thought everyone on the plane would find this exchange endearing instead of repulsive), the kid was pretending to break his dad's fingers and was actually trying to pull them back. The dad said, "Don't break Daddy's fingers. Dad needs his fingers to work. I'm very protective of my hands. How will I cut hair without my hands?" The kid, still yanking on his dad's fingers, replied, "I want to break them!!" "If you break them, how am I going to make any money to buy you things? I need my hands to work," the dad explained patiently. I frowned at this twisted logic. Shouldn't the kid not want to break his dad's fingers simply because it's the wrong thing to do? Was he teaching him that only in situations where it's financially profitable for you should you do the right thing? I tried to focus back in on my book, but at the same time was fascinated by their dynamic and couldn't help but listen.
At one point, the child said that he was not going to ski- clearly trying to get a reaction from his dad who wanted him to ski, but wanted him to go to ski school. Except it was all framed in the form of questions: "Don't you think it would be better for you to learn a little more and get a little better in ski school? Do you think you remember the pizza and french fries? Don't you think you need to practice a little more in ski school?" To which the child answered "no, yes, no." He was headstrong and adamantly opposed to going ski school. After a lot of back and forth, the dad tried to slyly change the subject and talked over the kid, who was still repeating that he was NOT going to ski at ALL. The dad squashed the kid's words, wack-a-mole style with his own words, and changed the topic of their conversation to the map of the United States on the complementary airline napkins. "That's where Daddy lives and that's where we came from. Here's where we're going," he explained. I have to say that as a teacher, I appreciated his attempt to infuse the flight and their ear numbing back and forth with some educational value. The kid paused for a second and said, "I want to go to Texas." He must have been pointing to the state, because his dad replied, "Wow, how did you know that was Texas?"
"I just know what shape it has."
"You're so smart! Is there a particular thing about Texas that interests you?"
"Dirt."
"Dirt?"
"They have a lot of dirt.... and if we were there, I could kick it at you."
The dad starts to change the topic again, but the kid continues, "I would make a big pile and just kick it at you!"
My jaw dropped. He could talk like that to his dad and get away with it?? I waited for the dad's reaction. I wished that one of those sensible British nannies from Nanny 911 would drop in, like an emergency oxygen mask, and give him a little guidance... but no such luck. Finally, I managed to tune them out and drift into sleep.